Go to Unsolved Mystery Publications Main Index Go to Free account page
Go to frequently asked mystery questions Go to Unsolved Mystery Publications Main Index
Welcome: to Unsolved Mysteries 1 2 3
 
 New Mystery StoryNew Unsolved Mystery UserLogon to Unsolved MysteriesRead Random Mystery StoryChat on Unsolved MysteriesMystery Coffee housePsychic Advice on Unsolved MysteriesGeneral Mysterious AdviceSerious Mysterious AdviceReplies Wanted on these mystery stories
 




Show Stories by
Newest
Recently Updated
Wanting Replies
Recently Replied to
Discussions&Questions
Site Suggestions
Highest Rated
Most Rated
General Advice
Ancient Beliefs
Angels, God, Spiritual
Animals&Pets
Comedy
Conspiracy Theories
Debates
Dreams
Dream Interpretation
Embarrassing Moments
Entertainment
ESP
General Interest
Ghosts/Apparitions
Hauntings
History
Horror
Household tips
Human Interest
Humor / Jokes
In Recognition of
Lost Friends/Family
Missing Persons
Music
Mysterious Happenings
Mysterious Sounds
Near Death Experience
Ouija Mysteries
Out of Body Experience
Party Line
Philosophy
Prayers
Predictions
Psychic Advice
Quotes
Religious / Religions
Reviews
Riddles
Science
Sci-fi
Serious Advice
Strictly Fiction
Unsolved Crimes
UFOs
Urban Legends
USM Events and People
USM Games
In Memory of
Search Stories:


Stories By AuthorId:


Google
Web Site   

Civil Disobedience -Does It Work? A Debate

  Author:  15070  Category:(Debate) Created:(3/18/2003 8:08:00 PM)
This post has been Viewed (967 times)

Civil Disobedience Training History of Mass Nonviolent Action

The use of nonviolence runs throughout history. There have been numerous instances of people courageously and nonviolently refusing cooperation with injustice. However, the fusion of organized mass struggle and nonviolence is relatively new. It originated largely with Mohandas Gandhi in 1906 at the onset of the South African campaign for Indian rights. Later, the Indian struggle for complete independence from the British Empire included a number of spectacular nonviolent campaigns. Perhaps the most notable was the year-long Salt campaign in which 100,000 Indians were jailed for deliberately violating the Salt Laws.

The refusal to counter the violence of the repressive social system with more violence is a tactic that has also been used by other movements. The militant campaign for women's suffrage in Britain included a variety of nonviolent tactics such as boycotts, noncooperation, limited property destruction, civil disobedience, mass marches and demonstrations, filling the jails, and disruption of public ceremonies.

The Salvadoran people have used nonviolence as one powerful and necessary element of their struggle. Particularly during the 1960s and 70s, Christian based communities, labor unions, campesino organizations, and student groups held occupations and sit-ins at universities, government offices, and places of work such as factories and haciendas.

There is rich tradition of nonviolent protest in this country as well, including Harriet Tubman's underground railroad during the civil war and Henry David Thoreau's refusal to pay war taxes. Nonviolent civil disobedience was a critical factor in gaining women the right to vote in the United States, as well.

The U.S. labor movement has also used nonviolence with striking effectiveness in a number of instances, such as the Industrial Workers of the World (IWW) free speech confrontations, the Congress of Industrial Organizations (CIO) sitdown strikes from 1935-1937 in auto plants, and the UFW grape and lettuce boycotts.

Using mass nonviolent action, the civil rights movement changed the face of the South. The Congress of Racial Equality (CORE) initiated modern nonviolent action for civil rights with sit-ins and a freedom ride in the 1940s. The successful Montgomery bus boycott electrified the nation. Then, the early 1960s exploded with nonviolent actions: sit-ins at lunch counters and other facilities, organized by the Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee (SNCC); Freedom Rides to the South organized by CORE; the nonviolent battles against segregation in Birmingham, Alabama, by the Southern Christian Leadership Conference (SCLC); and the 1963 March on Washington, which drew 250,000 participants.

Opponents of the Vietnam War employed the use of draft card burnings, draft file destruction, mass de-. monstrations (such as the 500,000 who turned out in 1969 in Washington, D.C.), sit-ins, blocking induction centers, draft and tax resistance, and the historic 1971 May Day traffic blocking in Washington, D.C. in which 13,000 people were arrested.

Since the mid-70s, we have seen increasing nonviolent activity against the nuclear arms race and nuclear power industry. Nonviolent civil disobedience actions have taken place at dozens of nuclear weapons research installations, storage areas, missile silos, test sites, military bases, corporate and government offices and nuclear power plants. In the late 1970s mass civil disobedience actions took place at nuclear power plants from Seabrook, New Hampshire to the Diablo Canyon reactor in California and most states in between in this country and in other countries around the world. In 1982, 1750 people were arrested at the U.N. missions of the five major nuclear powers. Mass actions took place at the Livermore Laboratories in California and SAC bases in the midwest. In the late 80s a series of actions took place at the Nevada test site. International disarmament actions changed world opinion about nuclear weapons.

In 1980 women who were concerned with the destruction of the Earth and who were interested in exploring the connections between feminism and nonviolence were coming together. In November of 1980 and 1981 the Women's Pentagon Actions, where hundreds of women came together to challenge patriarchy and militarism, took place. A movement grew that found ways to use direct action to put pressure on the military establishment and to show positive examples of life-affirming ways to live together. This movement spawned women's peace camps at military bases around the world from Greenham Common, England to Puget Sound Peace Camp in Washington state, with camps in Japan and Italy among others.

The anti-apartheid movement in the 80s has built upon the powerful and empowering use of civil disobedience by the civil rights movement in the 60s. In November of 1984, a campaign began that involved daily civil disobedience in front of the South African Embassy. People, including members of Congress, national labor and religious leaders, celebrities, students, community leaders, teachers, and others, risked arrest every weekday for over a year. In the end over 3,100 people were arrested protesting apartheid and U.S. corporate and government support. At the same time, support actions for this campaign were held in 26 major Cities, resulting in an additional 5,000 arrests.

We also saw civil disobedience being incorporated as a key tactic in the movement against intervention in Central America. Beginning in 1983, national actions at the White House and State Department as well as local actions began to spread. In November 1984, the Pledge of Resistance was formed. Since then, over 5,000 people have been arrested at military installations, congressional offices, federal buildings, and CIA offices. Many people have also broken the law by providing sanctuary for Central American refugees and through the Lenten Witness, major denomination representatives have participated in weekly nonviolent civil disobedience actions at the Capitol.

Student activists have incorporated civil disobedience in both their anti-apartheid and Central America work. Divestment became the campus slogan of the 80s. Students built shantytowns and staged sit-ins at Administrator's offices. Hundreds have been arrested resulting in the divestment of over 130 campuses and the subsequent withdrawal of over $4 billion from the South African economy. Central America student activists have carried out campaigns to protest CIA recruitment on campuses. Again, hundreds of students across the country have been arrested in this effort.

Nonviolent direct action has been an integral part of the renewed activism in the lesbian and gay community since 1987, when ACT UP (AIDS Coalition to Unleash Power) was formed. ACT UP and other groups have organized hundreds of civil disobedience actions across the country, focusing not only on AIDS but on the increasing climate of homophobia and attacks on lesbians and gay men. On October 13, 1987, the Supreme Court was the site of the first national lesbian and gay civil disobedience action, where nearly 600 people were arrested protesting the decision in Hardwick vs. Bowers, which upheld sodomy laws. This was the largest mass arrest in D.C. since 1971.

Political Analysis

Power itself is not derived through violence, though in governmental form it is usually violent in nature. Governmental power is often maintained through oppression and the tacit compliance of the majority of the governed. Any significant withdrawal of that compliance will restrict or dissolve governmental control. Apathy in the face of injustice is a form of violence. Struggle and conflict are often necessary to correct injustice.

Our struggle is not easy, and we must not think of nonviolence as a "safe" way to fight oppression. The strength of nonviolence comes from our willingness to take personal risk without threatening other people.

It is essential that we separate the individual from the role she/he plays. The "enemy" is the system that casts people in oppressive roles.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------

*NOW-THE ABOVE WAS BORROWED FROM THE "ACT-UP" WEBSITE

(http://www.actupny.org/documents/CDdocuments/CDindex.html)

There is already talk of "civil disobedience" should we actually go to war with Iraq.

1) DOES IT WORK?

2) WOULD YOU PARTICIPATE IN AN ANTI-WAR ACT OF CIVIL DISOBEDIENCE?

3) EXACTLY WHAT DO YOU THINK YOU CAN ACCOMPLISH?

seriously, why would you hurt yourself, and your family (loved ones), whe such illegal activity will not mean a hill of beans, when it comes to "foreign policy"?

You can join Unsolved Mysteries and post your own mysteries or
interesting stories for the world to read and respond to Click here

Scroll all the way down to read replies.

Show all stories by   Author:  15070 ( Click here )

Spring is coming

Replies:      
Date: 3/18/2003 10:11:00 PM  From Authorid: 56840    I would most certainly participate in civil disobediance if I was supporting something I believed in. But I do think that the war with Iraq is an awful but necessary measure to take. In practicing nonviolent acts in protest, people are not intentionally hurt, which I think is the best way to go, by speaking out and acting on what your values are based upon.  
Date: 3/18/2003 10:29:00 PM  From Authorid: 37900    There is a place for civil disobedience, generally where both sides remain civil and show some measure of respect for the views of the other. In those cases, it seems to be very effective. It is not, and should not be, the only option. I seem to remember about 100 people who recently went to Baghdad to act as human shields; apparently, since they are no longer there, they experienced the limits of civil disobedience.  
Date: 3/19/2003 6:56:00 AM  From Authorid: 15228    Isn't Civil disobedience really an act of violence? In California a group has threatened to disrupt a military Air base when war breaks out in Iraq. In a time of war I believe that can be called treason and the protestors put themselves and the airman at risk. The Air Force put out a statement that anyone who attempts to enter the base may be shot, it might be hard to tell if they are terrorists or protestors.  
Date: 3/19/2003 5:47:00 PM  From Authorid: 14407    1)Yes 2) Yes 3)Peace  

Find great Easter stories on Angels Feather
Information Privacy policy and Copyrights

Renasoft is the proud sponsor of the Unsolved Mystery Publications website.
See: www.rensoft.com Personal Site server, Power to build Personal Web Sites and Personal Web Pages
All stories are copyright protected and may not be reproduced in any form, except by specific written authorization
Other Cool Sites:
demo.strangemysteries.com 
demo.sportsolutions.biz 
demo.topsellingrealtor.com 
demo.personalebay.com 
demo.obe-astralprojection.com 
demo.yourfinancialaffairs.com 
demo.ilovemysteries.com 
demo.ezrlty.com 
demo.theinternetbusinessnetwork.com 
demo.renasoft1.com 
Awesome Free Web Graphics 
Favorite Grapic Quotes 
Greetings in Glittery Text 
Your name in Glittery Text 
www.thehomebusinessindex.com 
www.diet-food-weightloss-health.com 
www.investingandinvestments.com 
www.cancerinformationworld.com 
www.datinglovematchmaking.com 
www.creditinformationworld.com 
www.insurancelinksdirect.com 
www.ilovemysteries.com 
www.casinopokergambleing.com 
www.make-money-while-sleeping.com 
www.vacation-travel-cruse-deals-information.com 


.

Pages:653 101 1536 991 1244 537 404 1061 210 101 1518 301 1553 895 1075 1016 47 689 261 149 171 150 1178 1497 229 865 1565 1143 877 566 1124 475 1248 1555 250 415 276 331 749 842 20 11 566 421 1395 758 112 20 288 207 985 144 89 686 298 353 616 845 1404 691 237 478 1018 309 1597 950 746 1293 142 1221 1407 85 247 673 959 109 1335 730 824 798 407 490 1415 1419 1367 743 1256 495 744 401