Go to Unsolved Mystery Publications Main Index Go to Free account page
Go to frequently asked mystery questions Go to Unsolved Mystery Publications Main Index
Welcome: to Unsolved Mysteries 1 2 3
 New Mystery StoryNew Unsolved Mystery UserLogon to Unsolved MysteriesRead Random Mystery StoryChat on Unsolved MysteriesMystery Coffee houseGeneral Mysterious AdviceSerious Mysterious AdviceReplies Wanted on these mystery stories

Show Stories by
Recently Updated
Wanting Replies
Recently Replied to
Site Suggestions
Highest Rated
Most Rated
General Advice

Ancient Beliefs
Angels, God, Spiritual
Conspiracy Theories
Dream Interpretation
Embarrassing Moments
General Interest
Household tips
Human Interest
Humor / Jokes
In Recognition of
Lost Friends/Family
Missing Persons
Mysterious Happenings
Mysterious Sounds
Near Death Experience
Ouija Mysteries
Out of Body Experience
Party Line
Psychic Advice
Religious / Religions
Serious Advice
Strictly Fiction
Unsolved Crimes
Urban Legends
USM Events and People
USM Games
In Memory of
Self Help
Search Stories:

Stories By AuthorId:

Web Site   

Bookmark and Share

Billy the Kid and a Miracle in Historic Investigation!

  Author:  55967  Category:(Human Interest) Created:(7/3/2006 9:43:00 PM)
This post has been Viewed (8767 times)

Hello. If you have ever read anything about Billy the Kid or seen the Young Guns movies, you would have run across the mystery surrounding his death. There have been so many questions about what happened that night, and in consequence, there are so many variations to what happened, and they are so far apart that some have to do with the Kid not being killed at all. Some believe he rode off to become Brushy Bill Roberts, John Miller, or a host of other people.

Many historians have been quoted as saying to the effect of "We'll never know the truth now."

Oh yeah?

Something has recently come to light shedding truth on what happened that night. There can now be little doubt as to what happened.

First, let me explain that all of the different variations, including the ones where the Kid got away, agree that SOMETHING happened on the night of July 14, 1881. They all also agree that the main stage of what happened was in Pete Maxwell's house. Most, except for one, agree that it was in Pete Maxwell's bedroom.

***Before I reveal what has been found, here is a quick cover of a few variations and why they are murky. If you want, you can skip down to the end of these stars and pick up the post there to find out what was discovered.

Most agree that Pat went to Pete's bedroom in the dark, leaving his two deputies outside on the porch. He went in to wake Pete up to ask him about Billy. That's where the variations begin. In the official form, the Kid walked in and surprised Pat and Pete. He asked in Spanish who those guys were outside. Pat recognized his voice, and the Kid recognized a form. Billy asked Pete in Spanish who was sitting there. Pat rose up, firing twice. One hit Billy and the other ricocheted off the wall and smacked into Pete's headboard next to his head. The first had killed Billy. Pat and Pete ran out of the room and brought a lantern back in to see.

But the deputies said three shots were fired, not two. McKinney, one of the deputies, said Pat killed a Mexican by accident. Brushy Bill Roberts and other people said a long shoot-out ensued, and that they ran away. McKinney went on to say that Pat, frustrated at not killing the Kid, went to Paulita Maxwell's bedroom (the Kid's girlfriend), and waited there for him to show up and shot him with a shotgun. Others say that the whole headboard thing sounded like a made-up story. And there is the whole thing about getting the Kid buried quick. There are other discrepancies involved too, like two different coroner's reports, etc.***

So we will never know? Well, there was one quiet little statement made by a young, skinny girl after it happened, who was also there. That statement was put away and for whatever reason, never brought out and considered as reliable evidence. Her name was Paulita Maxwell, daughter of Pete and girlfriend of Billy's. It HAD to be brought out recently because of what we have found.

The Lincoln, New Mexico sheriff, partnered with another fellow, found a family still living in New Mexico whose members were direct descendants of Pete Maxwell. This family had inherited---and kept intact---Pete Maxwell's entire bedroom suite that he had from that night!! If you are a history buff at all, you can see the significance of this. Very few cases ever get breaks like this. And the markings match exactly the story of Paulita Maxwell.

First, the headboard is intact. No bullet holes. But here is Paulita's story. Pat sat on the bed and Billy came to the house looking for meat because he had heard that Pete killed a calf that day. He had no boots or hat on, only wore an undershirt, and carried a rather dull carving knife and a pistol. He was startled by the deputies, and opened the flap that hung over the bedroom doorway and entered the room where Pat sat with Pete. Billy asked who those guys were outside. Pat rose up and fired once, blinding himself with the flash and smoke. Not knowing where Billy went, not knowing he was dead, he dove for a corner. He looked up and saw something white above his head, and fired at it, believing it was the Kid.

He had fired into the bottom cabinet of the washing sink against the wall, according to Paulita.

We have that sink now. There is a .44 bullet hole right through it, and it matches the bullet from Pat's gun he had that night.

So now we know. We know that the Kid was killed that night, and we know what happened in that bedroom.

Paulita went on to say that the men left the room, came back with a lantern and put it on the windowsill to peer in before going in. She herself went in and put Billy's knife and gun in the top drawer of the dresser. Of course, they are not there now. There is a museum that supposedly has the knife and gun, but I don't know if they are authentic or not. Well, Paulita and the other women took the body to the carpenter's shop and layed him out, stuffing a rag in the hole in his back (where the bullet exited, leaving a big hole), and lit candles around the body until morning when the burial took place.

I wrote a short story that I posted on here called A Legend Launched in a Moonlit Night. I had already heard of Paulita's testimony, and for some reason, I believed it above the others and used it for my story. I guess I was right.

I think it is fascinating when you can pull details of history together like this and see exactly what did happen, and even have all the pieces together to look at. These historians really have lucked out.

P.S. The family who owns Pete's belongings wants to remain anonymous. I haven't heard if they are going to give it up to the public or not.

You can join Unsolved Mysteries and post your own mysteries or
interesting stories for the world to read and respond to Click here

Scroll all the way down to read replies.

Show all stories by   Author:  55967 ( Click here )

Halloween is Right around the corner.. .

Date: 7/3/2006 10:02:00 PM  From Authorid: 20750    Wowser very interesting. I'd love to see that stuff!  
Date: 7/3/2006 10:16:00 PM  From Authorid: 35160    wierd how so many legends came of this man. but kool that the truth has finally been discovered.   
Date: 10/31/2011 4:36:00 PM  From Authorid: 65271    why,does pat garette,never bring the body of billy back to collect the reward of 500$????
why was he burried on the spot the next morning??????
was brushy bill robert was realy billy the kid???? acording jesse evan,Jim McDaniels,along with Severo Gallegos, Martile Able, Jose Montoya, and Bill and Sam Jones, all of whom had known Billy the Kid,say he was.

Date: 11/11/2011 5:46:00 PM  ( From Author ) From Authorid: 55967    Cowboypete, hi. Of those you've mentioned, I personally know of only two concerning the topic, those being Jesse Evans and Severo Gallegos, both mentioned by Sonnischen and Morris in their book. With Evans, if I recall, he was found in Florida and only said that he knew the Kid was alive and living in Texas or something of the sort. If you can provide further sources, that would be great. One thing that closed the book for me regarding Brushy Bill was the picture of him standing beside the bed of J.Frank Dalton, who in the 1930's claimed to be Jesse James. Back then, Brushy claimed to be a member of his gang. With the other inconsistencies he put forth, I don't believe he was Billy, and believe that Billy was killed by Pat Garrette that night. As far as Pat not bringing back the body, well, I think I read that he felt he had enough witnesses to collect the reward anyway, and he tried to and failed. Remember too, it was in the heat of summer, and I wouldn't try bringing a body back anywhere in that kind of weather.  
Date: 11/11/2011 5:49:00 PM  ( From Author ) From Authorid: 55967    BTW, cowboypete, have you ever been on Lucas Speer's BTK website? Your name looks familiar.  

Find great Easter stories on Angels Feather
Information Privacy policy and Copyrights

Renasoft is the proud sponsor of the Unsolved Mystery Publications website.
See: www.rensoft.com Personal Site server, Power to build Personal Web Sites and Personal Web Pages
All stories are copyright protected and may not be reproduced in any form, except by specific written authorization

Pages:654 1128 759 1009 731 54 516 1335 1364 116 1247 1593 34 1372 1275 118 1036 1041 1047 64 602 1322 464 1434 1231 23 1402 1498 808 785 1038 423 1333 1306 1577 896 448 1169 1175 148 954 461 1264 1582 1545 405 1479 1196 728 1181 1380 9 1148 151 979 882 1515 86 65 951 128 189 1128 444 400 321 1486 710 784 826 207 1044 1094 1155 635 711 1238 493 518 1371 332 383 128 305 1037 1349 1190 39 1474 1524